I was one of those people.
"I will never own an e-reader," I said.
"I love the feel of books, the look of them, the smell of them...no e-reader for me!" I said.
And then one Christmas, must have been about 2009, I unwrapped a Kindle e-reader from my parents. It wasn't the first generation--I think it was the next after that--and I was instantly in love. I went through a spell where I didn't buy physical books at all. I could hear a book I wanted, and instantly download it. VoilĂ !
I found it especially useful when my younger son was born. It's a topic for another day, but I really struggled with breastfeeding my older son. It wasn't even because of actual obstacles--it was purely a result of my own head and the pressures I put on myself. Nursing was bonding, and I didn't allow any distractions...not even the TV. I quickly found out that, especially during growth spurts, babies can.nurse.forever. With my older son, I just wanted it to be done so we could get on to other stuff. With my younger son, I committed myself to just making nursing part of our normal routine. That meant that, yes, it was great bonding time, but no, I wasn't spending the entire time staring lovingly into my baby's (usually closed anyway) eyes. My Kindle was my secret weapon. There was no stress or pressure when he was nursing and I was engaged in whatever I was reading (at the time, I had only just discovered Game of Thrones and started reading through the books, so...yes, he was nursing and I was awash in the intrigue of Westeros).
In the years since, I've reached a fairly happy balance between physical books and e-books (my spouse might disagree...he's pushing back on my desire to have a bookshelf in every single room of the house for some reason...). But some people still have really big objections to e-readers. Here's a few of them.
They say that e-readers don't encourage reading comprehension the way that physical books do.
This is usually based on a 2014 study that showed the people reading a short mystery story recalled the events better when they had read it in paper form than electronic. The researchers had a few hypotheses about this, centering around the idea that the tactile experience aids in memory formation and later recall.
This isn't without basis. We know that memories are a complex ever-shifting tapestry of everything about a moment--sights, smells, sounds, feelings, even balance.
However, I find myself wondering if this is simply a case where the human brain hasn't adapted yet. I also wonder (and I haven't read the study for myself, so I don't know if they explored this) whether they controlled for people who were regular e-readers versus those who aren't. For me, I don't find any difference between recalling what I've read on my Kindle and what I've read in my books. Recently, I finished a
Cold Mountain hardcover and
The Good Earth as an e-book. At certain points, I was reading both novels at the same time. I only finished Cold Mountain this week, and The Good Earth a week or so ago, but I'm able to recall both stories equally vividly, at least by my estimation.
The human brain was never wired for reading and writing. Those are skills the brain has adapted to over the ages. Perhaps e-reading will be one that we adapt to also.
Source: http://mic.com/articles/99408/science-has-great-news-for-people-who-read-actual-books
They say that you need to be able to read long sentences.
And they are right. But I think this is more something we struggle with as internet readers than e-readers. I don't know that I've ever clicked a link in one of my Kindle books.
I do find myself tempted when I am reading online to click through to every link that I see. I have to commit to reading the entire portion of text and then clicking back through to see what the links were that I was interested in.
Source: http://mic.com/articles/99408/science-has-great-news-for-people-who-read-actual-books
Screentime hurts sleep patterns.
This is also true. Indeed, in my own life, I'm trying to shift away from having screens on right until bedtime.
But scientists have noted that e-readers like the original Kindle, which have no backlighting, don't have this issue the way that other mediums, like reading on tablets or smartphones, do.
Source: http://www.medicaldaily.com/e-books-are-damaging-your-health-why-we-should-all-start-reading-paper-books-again-317212
Anyway, to wrap it all up, I suppose this is like any other facet of our lifestyles: moderation is the best path.
At the end of the day, what matters is that people are reading. Perhaps our brains will catch up to the technology in time.